subscribe to current local breaking news  
The Shelter Island Reporter
Search Current Week
Official Newspaper of the Town of Shelter Island and the Village of Dering Harbor
For SUBSCRIBERS:
  Top Stories  
  Police Reports
  On the Street
  Sports  
  Editorials
  Columns
  Letters to the Editor
  Around the Island
  Calendar  
  Food & Wine
  Back Issues
  Digital Edition

FREE CONTENT:
  Holiday Guide
  Obituaries
  Slideshows
  Classifieds
  Legal Notices  
  Homeowners Network
  Community Links
  East End Businesses

FORUMS:
  Community Bulletin
   Board

  All Boards

  Send Letter to Editor
  Email us
  Subscribe Now
  Site Help
  News Tips
  Reader Survey

times/review online

  Contact/About

  Staff Roster

  Rates/Circulation


  The Suffolk Times

  The News-Review

  The North Shore Sun

  The Wine Press

Updated: 6/18/2009 - 4:20 AM



Making a case for East End drug court
Judge Rosenblum explains how problem-solving justice works at League of Women Voters meeting
  0 comments below

Judge Helen Rosenblum was the guest speaker at the League of Women Voters of Shelter Island's annual brunch, held on Saturday at the Pridwin. Enjoying the event were, from the left, President Cathy Kenny, Mary Dwyer, Hilary King, Judge Rosenblum, Phyllis Gates and Stephanie Lebowitz. Beverlea Walz photo
“There's been a lot of press on women judges lately but I can guarantee that Judge Sotomayor has never driven an ambulance,” proclaimed Cathy Kenney, president of the Shelter Island League of Women Voters as she introduced Helen J. Rosenblum. Judge Rosenblum, one of the two members of the Island's Justice Court and a long-time volunteer with the Shelter Island Red Cross Ambulance Corps, was the featured speaker at the League's annual meeting on Saturday, June 6 at the Gardiner's Bay Country Club.

Judge Rosenblum, who ran unopposed last November for her second term on the town bench, spoke passionately and eloquently of her work on the East End Drug Court — she is one of three judges in Suffolk County to serve on this panel that meets twice weekly in Southampton and Riverhead. The East End court is one of 175 drug courts in the state, but according to the judge, drug court is just one of the “problem-solving” courts in the county that are “dedicated to controlling aberrant and anti-social behavior.” Other areas covered include domestic violence, mental health, sex offenders and an “integrated” court that covers matrimonial disputes and domestic violence.

“New York State has met with tremendous success with our problem-solving courts and is often cited as a model for others,” the judge stated, citing a 2003 study that showed these specialty courts had saved the state some $275 million in prison-related expenses and had a 29 percent lower re-arrest rate (13 percent vs. 29 percent) after three years versus those offenders who opted to go to jail.

Yet drug court suffers from the misconception, she admitted, “that it is the easy way out, which it most definitely is not. We are not talking about a hug-a-thug type program.” Participants are subjected to rigorous and on-going evaluation, monitoring and counseling over the course of one to two years. Only non-violent addicts are accepted into the program and if they successfully complete it, the charges against them are dropped. “There are many people who appear before me who say ‘this just isn't for me; just send me to jail and get it over with,' but it's been proven that drug court is the better way to prevent future behavior than just serving jail time.”

The key to its effectiveness is a team approach that includes the judge, an assistant district attorney, the offender's lawyer (either a Legal Aid or private attorney), probation officer and coordinator. Only the coordinator receives compensation for this duty; all other members serve as a part of their regular responsibilities. The group meets every week but the participant may call on the services of the coordinator at any time and in high-risk cases, may be required to check in on a daily basis. If “weekly breath and urine tests indicate that the offender is clean, we all say ‘yea!' If they are not clean, they get a very different reaction from the court,” the judge said. Successful participation in the program culminates in a graduation ceremony, “an event never to be forgotten and always to be cherished … there's not a dry eye in the entire room.”

In closing, the justice said, “I believe that if, at the end of your days, you can say ‘not only was I the best person I could be but I did everything I could to help others,' then I think you've lived a good life. This drug court has given me that miraculous opportunity.”

The League also presented its programming for the upcoming year at this meeting, as well as the slate of officers. Phyllis G. Gates was nominated for vice-president, with the positions of vice-president for communication and the chair of the natural resources and education committees remaining open at this time.



Notice about comments:
The Shelter Island Reporter is pleased to offer readers the ability to comment on stories. We expect our readers to engage in lively, yet civil discourse. The Shelter Island Reporter does not edit user submitted statements and we cannot promise that readers will not occasionally find offensive or inaccurate comments posted in the comments area. Responsibility for the statements posted lies with the person submitting the comment, not The Shelter Island Reporter. Please be reminded, however, that in accordance with our Terms of Service and federal law, we are under no obligation to remove any third party comments posted on our website.




Add your comments below:










captcha 57b7128607a44bdc903b5578a0085849





0 comments found









Most Popular
  • VIEWED
  • COMMENTED


Voice your opinion

Start a discussion, join a discussion or make a comment.

Click "Community Bulletin Board" link on the left or "Discuss this story" link at the top of every story to get started.



summer wine press 2007