Riverhead body shop owner lands in prison
Gets two to six years for dealing drugs
37 comments below

Salvatore David Sapienza, 44, of Kings Drive, who was nabbed after police raided his East Main Street auto body shop, pleaded guilty to multiple drug and conspiracy charges in Suffolk County criminal court.
Law enforcement officers from the East End Drug Task Force made the June 2008 arrest after a months-long wiretap investigation, according to Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota.
At the time, police said they found 120 Vicodin tablets inside a drop ceiling in Mr. Sapienza's business, Sap's Auto Body, and a half-ounce of cocaine in a garage he rented on Route 58. Mr. Sapienza was arrested along with an alleged accomplice, Barbara Divello, 39, of Mattituck. Ms. Divello pleaded guilty to a fourth-degree conspiracy charge, an "E" felony that could carry a prison term of up to three years, but has yet to be sentenced, prosecutors said.
In the meantime, Mr. Sapienza's sister, Judy Thilberg will oversee the auto body shop, which will continue to operate and employ the same mechanics, Ms. Thilberg said.
She described her brother as a talented mechanic who was well-liked in the community, but had made mistakes. She also said she felt her brother got an unfair shake from the legal system.
Mr. Sapienza had a prior drug-related conviction in the 1990s for dealing cocaine in the Riverhead area, prosecutors said. In 1994, he pleaded to fourth-degree criminal possession of a controlled substance and was sentenced to five years' probation.
In connection with the 2008 arrest, Mr. Sapienza pleaded guilty before state Supreme Court Justice Robert Doyle to second- and fourth-degree conspiracy, two counts of third-degree criminal sale of a controlled substance, four counts of third-degree criminal sale of a controlled substance, fourth-degree criminal possession of a controlled substance and three counts of third-degree criminal use of drug paraphernalia.
Prosecutors had requested a sentence of six to 18 years.
vchinese@timesreview.com
The Riverhead News-Review is pleased to offer readers the ability to comment on stories. We expect our readers to engage in lively, yet civil discourse. The Riverhead News-Review does not edit user submitted statements and we cannot promise that readers will not occasionally find offensive or inaccurate comments posted in the comments area. Responsibility for the statements posted lies with the person submitting the comment, not The Riverhead News-Review. Please be reminded, however, that in accordance with our Terms of Service and federal law, we are under no obligation to remove any third party comments posted on our website.
37 comments found
BIG PIG HIDING : 6/23/2010
Dear Pig, I am glad to see you are still concerned about Dave"s well being .He is doing quite well,just finished school this week and got a passing grade,he still has his 3 squares on you and even more (He likes peanut MM's if you would like to send him some) I guess you are still a coward as big as ever since you have to hide behind a newspaper so no one can know who you are but we know you and your kind,My number is in the book if you would ever like to call or give me a buzz at the shop As for Dave being sneaky I guess it was who he hung around with that made him think he could be above the law drunken alcoholic PO s that covered up shootings in houses that involved their family drunken driving all the time boating while intoxicated yes we all know who it was with and they are no better then him or me,I consider you all low lifes compared to me PIG As for the tax man bring him on make a phone call or do whatever you want as for the LOVES they could not believe how incompetent that someone could be to give me the wrong stuff9we will not mention that SCPO name as not to embarass her but what other mistakes have they made to give a SAP a trailor that says LOVE MOTORSPORTS What a shame that you had to pay for the towing of these trailors with your tax money and mine also Business is doing quite well I would like to say Dave does have alot of friends who help out and do alot of good things for my family, you would be quite surprised as to who they are' Well gotta go call me any time for an update and don:t forget about the MM'S
Scammer all the way : 6/23/2010
All I know is that his entire life Sap has continued to think he is above the law - he obviously learned nothing from the past! Talk about wasting our taxpaying money - he is getting 3 squares a day and I am paying for it - meanwhile he lived the high life while dealing drugs. Because we both know that he was not paying any taxes with his business -come on big sister we know your salary as well as many others is being PAID OFF THE BOOKS!!! Nothing is legit with the Saps. Could care less about you actually, or your whole family for that matter. As for me hiding, I am not, I know you and don't really care for you. Therefore why would I want to see you? You are all a bunch of money hungry pigs!! Legal or not!! Hey you giving back the wrong trailer and race cars that Impound gave you, that you took knowing they were not your brothers? You are just as sneaky as him - I don't think Love would be feeling the "Love" over that one....ha ha ha!! LIKE I SAID....YOU ARE AS SNEAKY AS YOUR BROTHER!!
TWIN SISTER : 4/6/2010
TWIN SISTER TWIN SISTER WHERE ARE YOU LEO?
HEY BIG SISTER : 4/2/2010
HEY BIG SISTER HEY BIG SISTER WUT UP BIG SISTER
SAS Sister : 3/8/2010
To whoever Honey is I guess if you had it in you you wouldn"t be hiding behind a computer picking on Sap and his sister, I guess you know how it all went down 16 years ago too.Sap was not the Rat then either it was LW then. But He was not around when the gun went off and Leo disappeared but Im sure that there was 3 POs who know about that. Like I said keep hiding behind your computer,you must really care about Dave to keep so updated on him. I believe his family has moved on why don:t you too
RATS : 3/7/2010
Hey Big Sister don't call me HONEY first off!! Talk about a RAT - you just named all the people that rolled on your poor baby brother. FACE IT - IN THE DRUG WORLD - DAVE HAD NO FRIENDS WHEN IT CAME DOWN TO THEM OR HIM......AS YOU ALREADY KNOW!! There are no REAL friends when it is you ass behing bars or his!!! HE SHOULD ALREADY KNOW THIS FROM HIS PRIOR EXPERIENCE......................OF BEING A RAT HIMSELF WAY BACK WHEN!!! Get off your high horse and keep your nose in keeping his shop business alive while he is gone........instead of trying to defend him every chance you get. YES WE ALL READ THE PAPERS AND WE ALL KNOW SAP!!
SAP : 2/28/2010
Oh Oh to gross and all your other expressions that you have to say ,cause you must be a real piece of crap to hide behind a computer where you dont have to put your name,I guess you have nothing better in life to do but worry about Dave, did you read the paper IDIOT, he is doing his time,not hiding like his other friends who are just Rats and you pay for part of their salaries with your taxesone for the county, your guy you pay at an elementary school on Riley Ave., If you buy flowers from Homeside your looking at another one How about the guy at cablevision,How about the one at rep electric ALL the COKE HEADS who are hiding out there being rats so they didn:t go to jail, one thing Dave was not to them that they were to him RATS,Hell do his time while the rest of the rats hide out thinking nobody will ever know who they are but the list could go on and on and you would be surprised who they are. I KNOW who they are and they do too!!!!! AS for the trooper her and I are good friends so she won"t mind me wearing the jewelry.Get yourself a life Honey and learn how to use your name, I have a good job work 40 hours and can afford anything I want know it all. DAVES SISTER
THAT IS TO BAD FOR YOU : 2/28/2010
Seems Sap's BIG SISTER sees "only what she wants to see". If I was you I would not be bragging about all of the jewelry you are wearing that was meant for all the other women he bought them for.......they were all bought with DRUG MONEY which = BAD KARMA!! I don't think anyone is ever jealous of that! Yuck!! Ewww!! Gross!! Savor it Sis - now EVERYONE knows it is nothing you could ever afford :-)
SAP : 2/26/2010
To The KNOW IT ALL who knows all about where Dave got his ring,I guess you were there when he bought it . I don"remember seeing you there. maybe my eyes were going bad that day. Also when you see me I have the Troopers earrings in my ears and her diamond in a necklace around my neck ,so I guess it can:t be the same one his new girl has.Don:t be too jealous of me . DAVES BIG SISTER
HOW EMBARRASING!! : 2/26/2010
LOL!! THE DIAMOND RING HE GAVE THE TROOPER WAS THE SAME ONE HE GAVE TO HIS PREVIOUS GIRLFRIEND THAT SHE CUSTOM DESIGNED HERSELF- TALK ABOUT EMBARRASING. I GUESS HE WASN'T THAT RICH AFTER ALL....THE TROOPER GAVE HIM MORE JEWELRY....SEEMS SHE HAD MORE MONEY THAN HIM LOL!!
BooHoo : 2/25/2010
Has no one ever did something stupid when they were young?
~~~~~~~~
YOUNG?! He's in his 40s and a criminal.
sap : 2/20/2010
First, lay off the Trooper, people we love or are in love with do underhanded things that we can be completely unaware of, your kid might be high right now, your spouse might be doing the nasty with your best friend and you are clueless. Secondly, Druglord ! Kingpin ! please where are the kilos, the airplanes, the millions in street value drug product ?? ! A half ounce and a bag of pain killers , sounds like most housewives between the age of 25 and 40 . An automotive repair shop with drugs and partying….absolutely shocking ! Mechanics have always been known for clean living, tea and cookies, let’s see they like fast cars , hot women, fancy shoes some have desires that get them into trouble , and the desire for fast living and ambition get them into stupid situations where they make very bad choices. But these are also the guys who get out of bed at 3a.m. in the morning to tow you home in the rain from the expressway, also the same guys who look at your car, tweak some things and say , no charge, no big deal. I’m pretty sure that all of the electrical, mechanical repairs at Sap’s shop didn’t fix themselves, besides hauling in those obvious millions on drug deals , somebody was actually working. As far as hinting that his family is reaping some kind of benefit out of this bad, sad and embarrassing situation, F U ! Yes they will stand by his side, and they will forgive him, and they will pray for him and all others who go astray, that’s what family does . If your family and friends wouldn’t do that for you then you are truly a lonely soul, and this fact helps me understand your cold view of the world. People do stoopid stuff, people do wrong stuff, people will pay their dues here and elsewhere. He ain’t heavy, he’s my brother.
SAP : 2/19/2010
For all you who think you know everything,SAP Enterprise if you look it up is in the name of s David Sapienza along with everything else he owns ,So I guess all who thinks everything is in his family"s name don"t really know anything at all..
sap : 2/19/2010
are you for real????? the guy has been selling drugs for years. he didn't just come up with that when he turned 40. he sold and hid drugs at his place of business, may be that was convienient for you but it is illegal. what business owner puts all his assests in someone else's name??? someone who has something to hide!!!! when are you dope heads going to grow up especially if you have kids. give your kid a chance to be better!!!
Don't comment about things you don't know about : 2/18/2010
Dave is a much better person that 95% of you give him credit for being, that's because anyone who doesn't know him can call him scum for selling drugs. Maybe he did sell se drugs, but ringleader of some huge drug gang, come on, not even close. I'd also like to see a business owner that hasn't taken cash in exchange for no tax on a bill, are you serious. Bottom line..... He is a VERY nice respected, smart man, whom is well liked in te community. Did he sell a little bit of cocaine, maybe, any more than that is a our asumption and a lie. As far as putting his business in others name, what's wrong with being safe with your assets. Did anyone know he was selling drugs, like his fiancé or his family? The answer is NO, were they all benefiting from it NO. There was no lavish lifestyle, there was a guy who was a good mechanic that owned a repair shop that has been LINKED to no more than 20 grams of cocaine, 100 vicoden pills and a few small weight sales. People need to give the guy a break, he's in jail now are you happy? And if you think that solved your drug problem in riverhead then you probably haven't been there and shouldn't be making comments about people and things you don't know about. Give him a break it is what it is and he's doing the time. SAP Enterprises is running fine and will remain a profitable business because of what he made it. His frends and customers who know him will be right there when he gets out the same way they were before any of this mess. STOP BLOWING THINGS OUT OF PROPORTION!!!
SAP : 2/13/2010
As far as everyone knows the TROOPER is working in Lindehurst as a Trooper, make the call there and you will see. Know one will ever know the real story they can only guess what happened,as for the family there are 9 of them so Im sure they will all help him out, thats what most families do.
: 2/10/2010
No, he isn't the only one who did wrong; he put his business name, race car, personal vehicle and all asset accounts in his family's names. Doesn't that make them conspirators? They knew for years what he was doing; I'm sure they also profited indirectly. He will get out of jail in 2yrs max; and go back to doing the same thing without skipping a beat. He will have a butt load of money in his sister's name and a functioning business to welcome him back. The 2 women he was "dating" at the time were Divello and the trooper. Both have lost their six figure jobs and continue to face financial repercussions, as well as further legal issues. Sappy is the only one laughing and scamming his way down victory lane these days:)
Sap's a Liar : 2/10/2010
Dave (Sap) Sapienza is a lying, narcissistic idiot and his former fiance' didn't know a thing. Men (and women) like him can pull the wool over someone's eyes very easily, especially when that person is in love with them. Has no one ever been tricked by anyone? Please - give the girl a break. If the man or woman you loved swore to you that nothing was going on, and played that role very well, and hid everything of that "other life" from you you'd probably believe them too. And his past....Good God, everyone has a past. Has no one ever did something stupid when they were young? Granted, not many of us would sell drugs etc.. but come on, we've all made a wrong choice here and there. If everyone was judged by their past mistakes we'd all be in a deep pile of crap. Some people do change their ways and go on to be productive members of society. Some don't-and those eventually get caught.. Hence Sap sitting in jail-where he belongs. I just hope his current fiance or whatever she is see's it sooner if he doesn't straighten his act up this time around.
concerned : 2/9/2010
SAP's is not a Auto Body Shop!
Its an Auto Mechanical Repair shop!
Lets not connect the Auto Body Industry to this!
Dave Sapienza : 2/6/2010
Thomas Spota is as crooked as the boss on payday! you go mr. spota! lol
Ripping off the state : 2/5/2010
What about how he didn't collect tax if he got paid cash for work he did at the shop. The hole he's dug for himself could get pretty deep. Didn't he buy the trooper an expensive car right before the raid? What about that diamond he gave her. And all the other jewelry she got. All from drug money and ripping off the state. She had to know that. Does that stuff get turned over as part of the investigation?
State Attorney General Corrupt? : 2/5/2010
Thank You...author of "FEMALE STATE TROOPER".
We cannot be silent on this matter. No one is above the LAW. You imply in your views a corrupt state attorney general who is hiding something by not investigating this.. Interesting. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that the female trooper and maybe other troopers were very involved in this cover up conspiracy and police corruption. I also think some of Riverheads police are criminally involved and also guilty of conspiracy and corruption. After all SAP could just be the fall guy and the tip of the iceberg. According to his sister, Judy Thilberg, Dave was not the only one. also, I think Newsday and FOX 5 should be called on to investigate this story as it is very news worthy, and take it to the highest level. If our trust in our highest form of state security ( STATE POLICE) is breached then surely our civil rights won't be far behind. I implore anyone who knows the facts to come forward and address this issue in this forum, or any other news group. We must shame the truth out of the persons responsible for this cover-up. We will not be ignored. The truth is out there somewhere and it will always set every one free. And Why Not?
Female state trooper : 2/5/2010
Fact is, the female state trooper was brought to the attention of the state attorney general's office by Assemblyman Marc Alessi's office at my request. The AG chose to ignore the information. I know why they ignored it and it was not for acceptable reasons. SAP's sister is correct to say that her brother was not the only one who did wrong. For the female trooper who I am very familar with to say that she had no knowledge of what SAP, who she was engaged to be married to at the time, was doing is totally unbelievable. Obviously, I would and could have a lot to say to someone who is actually interested in the truth. I am not holding my breath.
good update : 2/4/2010
Vera, Thanks for the update.
This is a news worthy story because one, sap was a business owner and a business owner dealing drugs from his place of business is a serious matter in this town of high crime, stabbings, assaults and rapes. We must rid the town of these types for our town and childrens sake. Just as we have zero tolerance of drugs in our schools. Tolerance of drug sales in our community is just as grievous. Dave was not some low level dealer that you'd commonly find on riverhead's police blotter, he had an expansive network on the island. Some say not newsworthy, I beg to differ. The poison he dealt almost killed someone. Some say he was a nice guy, yeah he was nice if you bought coke from him. He was arrogant as they get. The Thurms family (a very respectable family) who owns the parking lot across the street form his business asked him to not park his junk cars on their property for a long time to no avail and at their cost, had to put up a fence to keep this scum from trespassing on their property with no help from the PD. The Riverhead police cuddled the creature for a long time. Dave's business was his front and should, and will be, confiscated by the state under the N.Y.S. drug forfeiture laws. So close it NOW before anymore embarrassment to our town. The state attorney general should be looking into this matter as it involves a female state trooper on the take and the cover up of her actions by internal affairs. The after hour coke parties at that repair shop and riverheads police involvement should also be investigated and published. I and a lot people I know use to have the utmost respect for the state police compared to the MAYBERRY police on the East End, but now that's even questionable. Until the truth comes out, no one on the entire East End should rest, and WHY NOT?
Vera, please keep us updated on this matter.
All in all : 2/2/2010
I am just glad that when his place was raided this time that Dennis, the Sarge, and the Lt didn't have their Super Boat in his "chop shop" this time getting discount work done!! When my dad was on the force he was told to avoid known felons and low level drug dealers, yet you could never pass "SAP" Enterprises without seeing a Cop car parked out front. And as for the "State Trooper " investigator??? She grew up in this town knew him and his history, attended the same high school and slept in the same circle of associates. She later becomes intertwined with this convicted and known felon, later living with and becoming engaged to him. She knew of his past conviction yet continued her relationship and claims to not know what he was into. What kind of "Investigator " was she?? Yea, the "Blue wall of silence" !! Yup, only outshadowed by the "Great Wall of the obvious" Sappo is a user, dealer, womanizer, and utimatly a fool, for I have never seen a successful drug dealer. He is like a cancer and destroys all he comes in contact with!! Hey Debbie, baby mama, way to go, you are not being used. Sap just waited till he was down and out and dumped by the trooper to get you back in his criminal life. Case in point!!!!
sap : 2/1/2010
Dave pleaded guilty to 12 counts, all his cohorts pleaded to various charges. He was wiretapped a month or more. He was an idiot. They had concrete evidence in his own voice. His trooper girlfriend lost alot at work, both now and in the furure. She was not involved but just played by SLICK DAVE.
sap : 2/1/2010
i agree that sap should be brought down to the level. Community service w/ probation might work.
coke : 2/1/2010
Yeahhh. The streets were really cleaned up by this one. A half ounce of coke, could do it in a weekend. Was it really worth the 2.9 million. Way too go. These over paid corrupt scum bags couldn't solve a jigsaw puzzel. Or connect the dots. Shoulda took that 2.9 million and investigated yourselfs
: 2/1/2010
My ownly comment and perception is the law is the law( they can lie and still get away with it, all those we will keep things confidential statements is definitely a lie, you can not trust any of the powers to be, but when the powers to be make it a personal vendetta it is sad that these are the ones we want to uphold the law How would the DA feel if it was there son or family member would they call the newspapers and everyother news broadcast to advertise a court outcome I can't ever remember a court outcome becoming headline news(unless of course it was John Gotti) after the 1st arrest is this something new we can expect for every person arrested we will have a follow up of their final outcome when settled in court or is this just because of SAP and the personal discruntincy's surrounding the whole case, not to mention the troopers own personal ex friends role to destroy Sap because of his relationship with her - of course not it would be hush hush, Be real this is the real world crooked and wronged its always the power of authority who feel they have control of anyones life but I strongly believe what goes around comes around so all those personal vendettas will come back at you. People make mistakes and the law is what does not allow them to move forward because after the mistake is made they are never given an opportunity to move forward so my only advise is to all the young please don't make a mistake in Riverhead, it will be held against you all your life unless you have family with authority figures otherwise your helpless......the statement of the pot calling the kettle black is such a true statement. SAP made mistakes as so many others so why is it none of them are headliners and why were so many given the option to make up statements against him to get a better deal? Is this law or is this Lets Make A DEAL? Is that not a mistake?
THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER IS.... : 1/31/2010
SAP GOT BUSTED FOR DEALING DRUGS WHICH IS ILLEGAL!! IF YOU DON'T WANT TO DO THE TIME - DON'T DO THE CRIME!! HE THOUGH HE WAS ABOVE THE LAW AS WELL!!
And you never have FRIENDS when you get busted and it comes down to you or them and he should have known this from his prior experience with the law!!!!
As far as the dirty cops - did you ever hear of the blue wall - well it is always going to be there and they are always going to get away with things that the common citizen doesn't. It is not fair, but unfortunately the truth!! However after all of this is said and done - the entire police force looks like a bunch of jerks!!! Not such great detective work I say!!
As far as sentencing these drug lords, as long as they are not killing people and all they are doing is pushing this crap around, hell I would rather they had to do some hard labor 7 days a week for 2 to 6 years around their own communities rather than sit on their ass in prison.
And that my friend is why our judicial system needs a serious overhaul!
Police - The Real Story : 1/31/2010
Unfortunately, once again, the police protect their own and get away with everything. It's really unfair that a State Trooper can be so personally involved and get away with a hand slap. This is the real story. We spend millions on police forces that put petty drug dealers away everyday, who cares. I want to know what penalty this Trooper faces. She is supposed to be an investigator and didn't know anything, sure. She definately knew of his prior convictions. I wish people, including cops, would start holding the police responsible for their actions. The problem is that cops don't want to risk their cushy jobs by causing internal issues. If the police would follow the same rules they enforce then the community would have much more respect for them. Vera, please follow-up with a story about this Trooper and how about some investigation into the constant rumors about Riverhead cops and coke. They have to live by the same laws we do.
Sad but True!! : 1/31/2010
The sad part of all of this is that Sapienza is a real nice, helpful, likeable guy that is an excellent mechanic and really has a talent. However drugs can ruin you! He is not perfect nor innocent, however I hope that when this is over he stays on the straight and narrow, as we all know in the end it is never worth it. I believe his business will go on without him and thrive even better when he returns. Let all the young kids learn a lesson here - when you have a god given talent - stick with it even if you don't make as much money as could being a crook - in the end it is never worth it.
SAP : 1/30/2010
How come sap is the only one mentioned,how above VLove who is in state BDivello pled to sale,R Palladino pled to conspiracy.Monica corso to poss,Mike Taylor being held in Riverhead jail on $500,ooo bail C Holmes,Andre Lee to conspiracyJScott Christy and T Thilberg Saps nephew Charges of conspiracy dropped. SAPS state trooper girlfriend suspended but back at work.They are just trying to destroy SAPS business
Prison : 1/30/2010
'Sentenced' means he's headed to prison. Probably by bus.
What is the truth? : 1/30/2010
So what is the real story - has he been sent to jail yet or still waiting around? If so, what jail and how much time will he do for real before he is let out? Sadly there are so many inconsistencies with this story!!
Drug Bust : 1/30/2010
This is way I never read any news report on AOL. amatuers.
coke : 1/29/2010
What about the dirty cops that he was doing coke with?
He got off lightly. Are the charges felonies or what? Does his chop shop go to the state?What did Divello get for her roll in this? This is shabby reporting by vera chinese. terrible.







